MRI After Ultrasound: Is It Really Necessary?

MRI-After-Ultrasound

Imaging technology for musculoskeletal injuries has been a game changer for practitioners whose treatment approaches depend on being able to see beneath the surface. Over the past several decades, MRI has been the imaging tool of choice due to its ability to provide clear still shots of ligaments, muscles, tendons and bones to reveal the locus and nature of damaged tissue.

Ultrasonography has been available for several decades as well, but early iterations of the technology provided unclear images that needed to be confirmed with MRI. However, recent advances in ultrasound technology have rendered it an accurate and in many cases preferable mode of soft tissue imaging.

Thanks to higher frequency transducers, significant increases in ultrasound image resolution make it possible to distinguish minute structures like individual nerve fascicles and tendon fibers. Power Doppler imaging allows for improved resolution of deeper structures.

Other advantages of ultrasonography over MRI include:

  • Small portable equipment
  • Ability to scan in real time while interacting with the patient
  • Higher special resolution than MRI
  • Enables dynamic examination of anatomic structures
  • Significantly less costly than MRI
  • Ultrasound can be used on patients with metal implants

Despite these distinct advantages, ultrasound should not be considered a competitor with MRI, but rather an imaging option that sometimes complements MRI. However, the question remains whether redundant imaging is in any way advantageous to the patient, or has any value in determining the clinical management of a musculoskeletal injury.

MRI After Ultrasound Studied

In a 2017 presentation at the American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine (AIUM) Conference, Dr. Lulu He, a musculoskeletal radiology fellow at the Cleveland Clinic, revealed the findings of a retrospective review of 129 cases over a four-year period, where MRI was prescribed within 90 days after the patient had received an ultrasound scan. In only one case was an abnormality found on MRI that had not been detected by ultrasound.

The researchers noted that some practitioners routinely order MRI after ultrasound, even when it is not recommended by radiologists. In particular, orthopedists are most likely to prescribe MRI after ultrasound, with the foot and ankle being the most common body parts examined, followed by the shoulder, hip and knee respectively. In only 19 of the 129 cases studied did radiologists recommend ultrasound to clarify ambiguous imaging findings.

The researchers concluded that an MRI performed after an initial ultrasound for musculoskeletal injuries is almost always in concordance with the ultrasound results, and clinical management strategies are rarely changed after an MRI.

Given the advantages of ultrasound over MRI, the inconvenience of MRI, and the expense incurred by patients with redundant imaging, it stands to reason that MRI should only be prescribed subsequent to ultrasound in cases where the interpretation of ultrasound imaging is ambiguous.

Musculoskeletal Injury Diagnosis and Treatment in NYC

The sports medicine team at NYDNRehab prides itself on accurate diagnosis of musculoskeletal injuries. We use diagnostic ultrasound imaging interactively with our patients to visualize the area of injury in real time, enabling patients to participate in their own diagnosis and treatment. Our state-of-the-art technologies combined with the experience and dedication of our staff make NYDNRehab the best rehabilitation clinic in NYC.

 

What to Do About Chronic Elbow Pain

For all its complexity, your elbow is a fairly rugged joint that can withstand high force loads. Nevertheless, overuse from sports like tennis or golf, repetitive occupational use, and carrying heavy loads with extended elbows can all lead to debilitating chronic pain. The first step to treatment is pinpointing the exact location and cause of […]

Read More (0)

October 25, 2017

Diagnosing Adductor-Related Groin Pain

Acute or chronic pain in the adductor and/or groin region Pain may also be felt in the lower abdomen Symptoms may be complex Symptoms decrease after warmup but increase with prolonged activity Impaired performance  

Read More (0)

June 3, 2018

130 West 42 Street, Suite 1055, New York, NY 10036
130 west 42 street, suite 1055 New York, NY 10036

Contact Us



You can call
or Send message
1-866-311-5889