When a patient visits a doctor because of low back pain, an MRI is often the first tool used to assess their condition. MRI stands for magnetic resonance imaging. This procedure is used to capture detailed images of internal body structures. An MRI of the back and spine detects problems like bulging discs, tumors and spinal stenosis. However, most causes of low back pain are not serious and are simply related to the normal aging process.
An MRI may provide peace of mind, but new research shows that in most cases the imaging procedure only adds a pain in the wallet on top of the patient’s back pain. Patients, hospitals and insurance providers not only foot the bill when it comes to the MRI itself, but also for $4,793 worth of extra costs according to a study led by a professor in the field of physical therapy.
An MRI often shows many changes and abnormalities of the back and spine, but most of these findings are benign. The patient then becomes concerned and puts a large amount of pressure on doctors to cure his or her condition. This results in the patient being referred for surgery, injections and specialist visits. These are costs that add up quickly.
Patients often ask for these services even in the absence of pain, discomfort or symptoms. A common example is a degenerative disease of the discs in the spine, which is a normal result of growing older. The majority of people over the age of 50 have a noticeable amount of degenerated discs present on MRI, but the condition usually does not progress to the point where it causes pain or discomfort. The study found that when patients get this diagnosis from an MRI, they usually ask for treatment.
Pain in the lower back is one of the most prevalent and disabling health problems worldwide. People spend more time out of work due to back pain than other more serious conditions, such as cancer, traffic injuries and childbirth.
According to this research, $86 billion was the worldwide price tag of lower back pain treatment in 2005. Add that to the billions of dollars worth of lost hours each year and it becomes obvious that back pain is a costly epidemic. However, we found that there are more cost-effective methods for treating back pain.
A better option for most patients complaining of low back pain is to send them to physical therapy first instead of performing an MRI. The study found that patients who opted for this route were only out an average of $1,181 in treatment costs during the year after their first visit to the doctor for their back pain. Patients who received an MRI first spent $6,664 during the same amount of time.
When low back pain patients go to physical therapy, the therapist educates them about the causes of their pain and steps they can take to reduce it on their own. The study speculated that patients who chose this option were more engaged with their therapy and more motivated for success in their own recovery, while patients who went with surgery or injections expected a quick fix.
Beginning treatment with physical therapy rather than an MRI does not rule out the option of having an MRI if needed. When a patient has specific symptoms that suggest a more serious problem, or if the pain persists or worsens, a physical therapist may recommend an MRI for the patient. Doctor said that advanced imaging has its place, but that place is not in the beginning of treatment for the majority of patients.
Many people are used to diagnostic tests like imaging as the first line of treatment. It makes sense for some ailments, such as x-rays to check for cavities or broken bones, but many other conditions including low back pain are better assessed through other means. The study observed that patients often find it unacceptable when imaging is denied or discouraged in favor of physical therapy or other treatments first.
Physicians can help patients by explaining the monetary savings of trying physical therapy first. Using physical therapy as the first-line treatment instead of an MRI also leads to a less invasive treatment plan going forward, according to the study. Most patients find that physical therapy improves their symptoms to the extent that they no longer seek other treatments. Physicians can also point out that there is no harm in trying physical therapy and that other treatments can always be tried later if the patient does not improve.